Westminster Skeptics – Frank Swain, the Science Punk

Last night’s Westminster Skeptics talk by Frank Swain, the Science Punk, offering ‘A critique of skepticism’. It was interesting stuff – and you can hear it in full here (aside from 3 minutes removed for legal reasons). Also features Councillor John Dixon.

FacebookEmailRedditPinterestTwitterTumblrShare

10 comments

  1. Jack of Kent says:

    The “legal reason” is simple.

    A highly offensive – vile – comment about Gillian McKeith is referred to. My recollection is that, in the context it was mentioned, it would be legally ok to broadcast. However, I would want to re-hear it to be certain.

    But given the interest in Frank’s (brilliant) talk, James wants to get the podcast out as soon as possible. I will not have time to listen to it until this evening.

    As the Pod Delusion is a responsible podcast, James and I agreed a compromise: an edited version can go out straight away; and when I have listened to the reference to Gillian McKeith again, it may be possible to put the unedited version online too.

    I am sorry if this edit causes an inconvenience.

  2. A link to the mp3 please?

  3. I found it a very interesting evening. I made some comments using Socratic Questioning, which I’ve expanded on here: http://arkadychenko-theblog.blogspot.com/2010/08/on-westminister-skeptic-and-problem.html

  4. [...] Humbug 101 podcasts), but I felt there were plenty in there.  I’ve re-listened to the talk via Pod Delusion and my initial doubts have been [...]

  5. [...] Swain (Science Punk) gave a superb talk on the problems with the skeptic movement at Westminster Skeptics in the Pub. A podcast of his talk is now up, and it’s a must-listen. [...]

  6. [...] 13th, 2010 § 0 I’m listening to the pod delusion, in the middle of the night, with the dogs sleeping around me and my teenager pretending to sleep [...]

  7. [...] Posted by dellybean on August 6, 2010 · 2 Comments  On Monday 2nd August, Frank Swain (@SciencePunk), a science writer, gave a talk to the Westminster Skeptics (#WestSkep), entitled “Skeptical about Skeptics”.  A podcast of which can be found here. [...]

  8. [...] This was a version of a talk originally given to Westminster Skeptics in the Pub – you can hear the original here. [...]

  9. [...] said a similar thing in his Skeptical About Skeptics piece, and his accompanying SitP talks at Westminster SitP and Winchester SitP. Skeptics are only talking to fellow skeptics at these events – they are [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Visit Us On TwitterVisit Us On FacebookVisit Us On YoutubeCheck Our Feed