Last night’s Westminster Skeptics talk by Frank Swain, the Science Punk, offering ‘A critique of skepticism’. It was interesting stuff – and you can hear it in full here (aside from 3 minutes removed for legal reasons). Also features Councillor John Dixon.







The Pod Delusion is now broadcast on Resonance 104.4FM in London on Fridays at 1pm. You can find out more about Resonance FM and listen to their live stream on their
The “legal reason” is simple.
A highly offensive – vile – comment about Gillian McKeith is referred to. My recollection is that, in the context it was mentioned, it would be legally ok to broadcast. However, I would want to re-hear it to be certain.
But given the interest in Frank’s (brilliant) talk, James wants to get the podcast out as soon as possible. I will not have time to listen to it until this evening.
As the Pod Delusion is a responsible podcast, James and I agreed a compromise: an edited version can go out straight away; and when I have listened to the reference to Gillian McKeith again, it may be possible to put the unedited version online too.
I am sorry if this edit causes an inconvenience.
A link to the mp3 please?
[...] Full length podcast from The Pod Delusion [...]
I found it a very interesting evening. I made some comments using Socratic Questioning, which I’ve expanded on here: http://arkadychenko-theblog.blogspot.com/2010/08/on-westminister-skeptic-and-problem.html
[...] Humbug 101 podcasts), but I felt there were plenty in there. I’ve re-listened to the talk via Pod Delusion and my initial doubts have been [...]
[...] Swain (Science Punk) gave a superb talk on the problems with the skeptic movement at Westminster Skeptics in the Pub. A podcast of his talk is now up, and it’s a must-listen. [...]
[...] 13th, 2010 § 0 I’m listening to the pod delusion, in the middle of the night, with the dogs sleeping around me and my teenager pretending to sleep [...]
[...] Posted by dellybean on August 6, 2010 · 2 Comments On Monday 2nd August, Frank Swain (@SciencePunk), a science writer, gave a talk to the Westminster Skeptics (#WestSkep), entitled “Skeptical about Skeptics”. A podcast of which can be found here. [...]
[...] This was a version of a talk originally given to Westminster Skeptics in the Pub – you can hear the original here. [...]
[...] said a similar thing in his Skeptical About Skeptics piece, and his accompanying SitP talks at Westminster SitP and Winchester SitP. Skeptics are only talking to fellow skeptics at these events – they are [...]